Most car accident claims are resolved without a trial. Whether a case proceeds to court depends on factors such as liability, the severity of the injuries, the evidence available, and whether the parties can reach a fair settlement. Sabbeth Law helps people injured in car accidents in Vermont and New Hampshire understand their options and prepare their claims for either settlement or litigation.

An Analysis of How Often Car Accident Cases Go to Court

The short answer is: relatively few car accident cases reach a trial.

The most useful nationwide data comes from the U.S. Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS). Its Civil Justice Survey of State Courts found that bench and jury trials accounted for approximately 4% of tort case dispositions in 2005. Motor vehicle accident cases made up nearly 60% of the tort cases that went to trial.

That statistic is useful for understanding the general picture, but it has an important limitation: the BJS study is based on 2005 data. There is no comparable recent nationwide dataset that establishes a current trial percentage specifically for car accident claims. For that reason, it would be misleading to present the 4% figure as a current Vermont or New Hampshire trial rate.

The practical takeaway remains straightforward: filing a claim does not necessarily mean you will have to testify before a judge or jury. Many claims are resolved through negotiations before trial, while others may require a lawsuit to obtain a fair result.

How Often Do Car Accident Cases Go to Court Exploring Legal Trends understanding

A car accident claim typically begins outside the courtroom.

The first stage involves understanding what happened and documenting the resulting injuries and losses. This may include reviewing the police report, photographs, witness statements, medical records, vehicle damage, insurance information, and other available evidence.

Once the facts and damages are sufficiently documented, a claim may be presented to the appropriate insurance company. The parties may then negotiate over liability and the amount of compensation.

If the insurer makes a fair offer, the case may resolve without litigation. If the insurer denies responsibility, disputes the severity of the injuries, or refuses to offer reasonable compensation, filing a lawsuit may become necessary.

Importantly, filing a lawsuit does not automatically mean the case will go to trial. Many cases continue to settle after litigation begins.

Contact Us

Why Do Some Car Accident Cases Go to Court?

Several factors can make litigation more likely.

Disputed Liability

If the drivers disagree about who caused the collision, the insurance company may refuse to accept responsibility. Evidence such as photographs, vehicle damage, traffic-camera footage, witness testimony, police reports, and accident reconstruction may become important in resolving the dispute.

Serious or Long-Term Injuries

The greater the consequences of an accident, the more significant the potential damages may be. Cases involving traumatic brain injuries, spinal injuries, permanent disabilities, or substantial future medical needs can involve substantial disagreement about the value of the claim.

Disagreement About the Value of the Claim

An insurer may acknowledge that its policyholder caused the accident but disagree about how much the injured person should receive.

The dispute may involve medical expenses, lost income, reduced earning capacity, pain and suffering, or future treatment.

Questions About Preexisting Conditions

Insurance companies sometimes argue that an injury was caused by a preexisting condition rather than the accident. Medical records from before and after the collision can become important when establishing what changed because of the crash.

Multiple Potentially Responsible Parties

A collision involving multiple drivers, a commercial vehicle, a defective vehicle component, or dangerous roadway conditions can create additional legal questions. Determining each party’s responsibility may require a more extensive investigation.

An Insurer Refuses to Make a Reasonable Offer

Even when liability appears relatively clear, settlement negotiations can fail because the parties have very different views of the claim’s value. When that happens, litigation may be necessary to pursue the compensation available under the applicable law.

Does Going to Court Mean Your Case Will Go to Trial?

No. This distinction is important.

A lawsuit can be filed without ultimately reaching a trial. Once a case enters litigation, the parties generally have opportunities to exchange information, take depositions, obtain additional evidence, participate in mediation, and negotiate a settlement.

A case can therefore resolve at several points before a judge or jury decides the outcome.

Even after a car accident trial begins, settlement may still be possible. Preparing a case for trial can also strengthen a party’s negotiating position because both sides know that the matter is ready to proceed if an agreement cannot be reached.

Contact Us

What Happens If a Car Accident Case Goes to Trial?

If a case does proceed to trial, the process is more formal than settlement negotiations.

Jury Selection

In a jury trial, potential jurors are questioned during the selection process to determine whether they can fairly evaluate the evidence.

Opening Statements

Each side explains its position and what it expects the evidence to establish.

Presentation of Evidence

The parties present documents, photographs, medical records, expert testimony, and other evidence. Witnesses may testify and can be questioned by the opposing side.

Closing Arguments

After the evidence has been presented, each side summarizes its position and explains why the judge or jury should rule in its favor.

Decision

The judge or jury then determines the issues presented at trial. Depending on the case, the decision may address liability, damages, or both.

The exact procedure can differ between Vermont and New Hampshire and depending on the type of case.

How Long Does a Car Accident Case Take?

There is no universal timeline.

A straightforward claim may resolve relatively quickly if liability is accepted and the extent of the injuries is clear. A case involving serious injuries, disputed fault, extensive medical treatment, or litigation can take substantially longer.

The timeline may also depend on whether the case settles before a lawsuit, settles during litigation, or proceeds through trial and potentially an appeal.

It is therefore better to focus on what needs to happen before the claim can be fairly resolved rather than relying on an arbitrary number of months.

For example, settling a claim before the injured person’s medical condition is understood may result in an inadequate assessment of future losses. Conversely, unnecessary delays can make it harder to preserve evidence and meet legal deadlines.

What Can Increase the Chances of Reaching a Fair Settlement?

Strong preparation can make a significant difference.

Preserve Evidence

Keep photographs, videos, police reports, medical records, bills, correspondence with insurers, and other documents connected to the accident.

Follow Medical Advice

Follow your healthcare provider’s treatment recommendations and attend follow-up appointments. Gaps in treatment may give an insurer an opportunity to question the severity or cause of an injury.

Document Your Losses

Keep records of medical expenses, missed work, reduced income, transportation costs, and other financial consequences associated with the accident.

Establish Liability

A strong claim should be supported by evidence rather than assumptions about who caused the collision.

Understand the Applicable Deadline

The time available to file a lawsuit varies by jurisdiction and by the type of claim.

In Vermont, 12 V.S.A. § 512 generally provides a three-year period for actions involving personal injuries caused by another person’s act or default, with the statute providing that the cause of action accrues on discovery of the injury. Other statutes and exceptions can apply depending on the circumstances.

Because limitations periods can be affected by the specific facts, an injured person should not assume that the general three-year period applies to every claim.

Should You Be Worried About Going to Court?

The possibility of going to court should not prevent you from pursuing a legitimate car accident claim.

A lawyer’s role is not simply to take every case to trial. The goal is to determine what resolution makes sense based on the evidence, the applicable law, the injuries involved, and the compensation available.

If a reasonable settlement can be reached, resolving the case without trial may make sense. If an insurer refuses to provide fair compensation, being prepared to litigate can give you another avenue for pursuing your claim.

The important point is that you should not accept an inadequate settlement simply because you are worried about going to court.

Vermont and New Hampshire Car Accident Claims

Sabbeth Law represents injured clients in both Vermont and New Hampshire. Because personal injury laws and procedural requirements can differ between the two states, the location and circumstances of the accident matter.

An attorney can evaluate the applicable law, investigate the facts, assess the available insurance coverage, and determine whether negotiation or litigation is appropriate.

For Vermont claims, this may include analyzing the state’s negligence and comparative-fault rules as well as applicable filing deadlines. For New Hampshire claims, the applicable statutes and court procedures must likewise be considered.

A case should be evaluated on its own facts rather than assuming that a rule from another state applies.

How Sabbeth Law Can Help With Your Car Accident Claim

At Sabbeth Law, we understand that the possibility of litigation can make an already difficult situation feel more stressful.

We help clients in Vermont and New Hampshire understand what their claims involve and what options may be available. Our work may include investigating the accident, gathering evidence, documenting damages, communicating with insurers, negotiating settlements, and preparing cases for litigation when necessary.

Our approach is to prepare each claim thoroughly while keeping settlement open when it is in the client’s interests. If a fair resolution cannot be reached, we can help you understand the next steps involved in pursuing the claim in court.

Contact Sabbeth Law to discuss your car accident claim. 

FAQs About Car Accident Cases and Court

Do most car accident cases go to trial?

No. Available nationwide BJS data shows that approximately 4% of tort case dispositions in its 2005 study were resolved through a bench or jury trial. Motor vehicle accidents were the most common type of tort case among those that reached trial. The data is historical, however, and should not be treated as a current trial rate for Vermont or New Hampshire.

Does filing a car accident lawsuit mean I have to go to trial?

No. A lawsuit can settle at many stages before trial. The parties may negotiate, exchange evidence, participate in mediation, or reach an agreement during other stages of litigation.

What makes a car accident case more likely to go to court?

Disputed liability, serious injuries, disagreements about damages, multiple potentially responsible parties, questions about preexisting conditions, and an insurer’s refusal to make a reasonable settlement offer can all increase the likelihood of litigation.

How long does a car accident case take if it goes to court?

There is no fixed timeline. A case involving straightforward facts may resolve relatively quickly, while cases involving serious injuries, expert witnesses, disputed liability, or extensive discovery can take considerably longer.

Will I have to testify if my car accident case goes to court?

You may need to testify if your case proceeds to trial, particularly if your account of the accident, your injuries, or their effect on your life is relevant to disputed issues. Your attorney can explain what testimony may be required and help you prepare.

Contact Us